Skip to content
Go back

Tender Offers: Sell Startup Stock or Hold?

By KingPin 12 min read
Tender Offers: Sell Startup Stock or Hold?

Your Net Worth Is One Company, and It Just Offered You an Exit

Your startup is sending out a tender offer, and your paper net worth is mostly that one company’s stock. The verdict: sell a meaningful slice, somewhere around 20% to 50% of what you’re allowed to sell, unless you could shrug off the stock going to zero. Then spend your real effort on two things: which kind of share you’re selling, and the paperwork.

The share type decides whether you owe long-term capital gains tax (23.8% federal at the top) or ordinary income tax (up to 37%). On a $180,000 gain, that gap is about $24,000. Nobody mentions that at the all-hands.

Tender Offer vs. Secondary Sale: Who Is Actually Buying?

Both let you sell private stock before an IPO. They are different machines.

A tender offer is a structured, one-time window. The buyer is either the company itself (a buyback) or outside investors the company has invited in. The company writes the rules: price, who can sell, how much, and the deadline. You get an “offer to purchase” document, and you opt in or ignore it.

A secondary sale is you finding your own buyer, usually through a platform like Forge Global, EquityZen, Clarity (called Hiive until a September 2026 rebrand) or Nasdaq Private Market. Carta also runs liquidity programs on top of its cap table software. The buyer is an accredited investor or fund, and the company has to approve the transfer.

A few rules of thumb on tenders:

The Tax Bill Depends on the Share Type

Use the 2026 numbers from IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-32:

At a high income, the long-term rate is 23.8% (20% plus 3.8%) and the ordinary rate is 35% to 37%. Now the share types.

Shares you already own (exercised more than a year ago)

This is the clean case. You exercised, you held for more than a year, and now you sell. The whole gain is long-term capital gain.

Example: you bought 10,000 shares at $2 and the tender price is $20. Gain: $180,000. Federal tax at 23.8%: $42,840.

ISOs: exercise and sell in the tender

If you exercise incentive stock options and sell in the same tender, you have a disqualifying disposition. You haven’t held the shares 1 year from exercise and 2 years from grant, so the spread is ordinary income.

Same 10,000 options, $2 strike, $20 tender price, and you’re in the 35% bracket. The $180,000 spread is ordinary income: $63,000 federal. Had it been long-term gain at 23.8%, it would be $42,840. The shape of the sale cost you $20,160.

One piece of good news. Statute IRC 3121(a)(22) excludes ISO exercises and later sales of the stock from FICA wages. You owe income tax on the spread but no Social Security or Medicare tax. Unlike an NSO, a disqualifying ISO sale has no required income tax withholding, so you may owe estimated tax. Plan for that.

ISOs you exercised earlier and held

If you exercised more than a year ago and the grant date is more than 2 years back, you have a qualifying disposition. The gain from strike to sale price is long-term capital gain. The AMT detail: if the exercise spread pushed you into AMT back then, you paid tax on a paper gain and got an AMT credit carryforward. The 2026 AMT exemption is $90,100 single and $140,200 joint, phasing out starting at $500,000 and $1,000,000 of income. The credit only comes back in years when your regular tax exceeds your tentative minimum tax, and a big qualifying sale is often one of those years. If you carry a credit, have your tax preparer model the sale year before the tender closes.

NSOs

Non-qualified options are simple and painful. The spread at exercise is W-2 wages, ordinary income, with income tax withholding and FICA. Exercise at $2, sell at $20 in the tender, and the full $18 per share is wages. Any extra gain between exercise and sale is capital gain, and it is usually zero in a same-day exercise-and-sell.

Private-company RSUs

Most private-company RSUs have two triggers: a time-based vest and a liquidity event. Some tenders let you sell RSUs that have vested but not settled. When they settle, the full value is ordinary income with withholding. The company often withholds shares to cover tax, which shrinks what you actually sell. If your sale price is above the settlement value, the extra is capital gain.

The Compensation Trap: When the Price Is Too Good

This one gets lawyers arguing. Suppose the company buys your common stock at $20, but its most recent 409A valuation says common stock is worth $12. The $8 difference looks like a gift. Practitioner guides say the IRS can treat that excess as compensation, taxed as ordinary income with payroll tax, instead of capital gain. Companies also record the excess over fair value as stock-based compensation expense in their financial statements. No IRS ruling or regulation settles this, so treat it as a real risk and not a settled rule. The risk is highest when the company itself funds the tender and sets the price.

What to do about it:

  1. Find the 409A valuation date and the price. Compare it to the tender price.
  2. If the tender price is at or below fair value, you’re in the clear on this issue.
  3. If it is above, read how the company says it will report the excess (W-2 or 1099-B).
  4. Ask HR or the equity team in writing. You want the answer before you tender, not on a January W-2.

QSBS: Redemptions Can Matter

If your stock might qualify as qualified small business stock under IRC 1202, a company redemption can disqualify other shares. The statute disqualifies stock issued within windows around a corporate buyback from the same person, and around “significant” buybacks above 5% of the company’s stock value. Shares you buy on a secondary market are not original issuance, so they can’t be QSBS in your hands. For stock issued after July 4, 2025, the exclusion is 50% after 3 years, 75% after 4 and 100% after 5. A tender where outside investors buy your shares is not a company redemption, so this issue applies to company buybacks. That includes a hybrid tender where the company buys part of the shares, and a ROFR where the company steps in on your secondary sale. If you have QSBS in a startup, ask the company counsel whether the tender triggers a redemption problem. Do not guess.

Secondary Platforms: Slower and Pricier

On a platform, you list shares and the platform finds a buyer. Then the paperwork starts.

A Worked Decision: $600k of Paper, $250k Everywhere Else

You have $600,000 of startup stock (paper value) and $250,000 in everything else. That is $850,000 total, and 70.6% of it rides on one company.

SellCash out (pre-tax)Startup stock leftOther assetsStartup share of net worth
0%$0$600,000$250,00070.6%
25%$150,000$450,000$400,00052.9%
50%$300,000$300,000$550,00035.3%

The floor matters more than the percentages. If the startup goes to zero tomorrow, you keep (pre-tax) $250,000 at 0%, $400,000 at 25%, and $550,000 at 50%. Ask yourself the zero question directly: if this stock went to zero tomorrow, would you be okay? If the answer is “no,” sell more. If it is “yes, but I’d be sad,” 25% is a sensible slice.

Your $600,000 stake could be worth $3,000,000 in four years. Selling 25% still leaves you 75% of that upside. The math doesn’t care how great the product demo was. Selling half of a bet you can’t hedge isn’t betrayal. It is portfolio construction.

Some of that $150,000 goes to the IRS, so run the numbers by share type first. A discount to the preferred price is the cost of liquidity, and it doesn’t make a sale a bad idea.

Gotchas Before You Sign

Common Questions

Do I have to pay taxes when I sell shares in a tender offer?

Yes. The sale is taxable. The rate depends on the share type. Shares held more than one year are long-term capital gain, up to 20% federal plus 3.8% NIIT. Exercised options sold at once are often ordinary income, and vested RSUs that settle at sale are also ordinary income.

Do ISOs get long-term capital gains in a tender offer?

Only if you held the shares more than 1 year after exercise and more than 2 years after grant. An exercise-and-sell in the tender is a disqualifying disposition, so the spread is taxed as ordinary income. ISO sales are exempt from FICA, so no Social Security or Medicare tax applies to the spread.

How long does a secondary sale of private stock take?

A secondary sale commonly takes 1 to 3 months. Clarity (formerly Hiive) says 30 to 90 days from the signed share transfer notice. The company approval step and a right of first refusal window, often around 30 days, drive most of the delay. A blocked transfer can end the deal.

Do I need to be an accredited investor to sell my startup shares?

No. Secondary platform buyers must be accredited investors, not sellers. An employee with no accredited status can register as a seller only. The company still has to approve the transfer, and the sale may be subject to company transfer rules.


Share this post on:

Send a Webmention

Written about this post on your own site? Send a webmention and it'll show up above once verified.


Previous Post
Crypto Position Sizing for the Tempted
Next Post
Paying for a Kid: DCFSA vs the Tax Credit

Discussion

Powered by Garrul . Sign in with GitHub or Google, or post anonymously.

Related Posts